Friday, March 7, 2014
If you don't like the word, take the substance
Some people are reluctant to use the word federalism, perhaps because it
would imply recognizing that the individuals and parties that always
defended it were right. But more and more people throughout Europe
recognize that it provides the values and the ideas that are necessary
to solve the problems of national minorities and divided loyalties that
plague Europe and many other parts of the world. Now it is Ukraine,
Scotland or Catalonia. Tomorrow it can be many other places. Today it is
again the Financial Times, whose editorial pages have several times endorsed federalism, that includes a column by David Gardner
saying exactly that: "The eventual answer to this problem does not have
to be either separatism or unionism (monarchy is a secondary issue). It
could as well be a
creative form of federalism, even though federalism as a word, let alone
a formula, sends semantic shivers up the political spine of both
countries. Yet if the majority nationalists – also known as
unionists – were to look more empathetically at their minority
nationalists, they might detect the ambiguities and hesitancy behind
much separatist discourse. Surely it has occurred to all three capitals
(London, Madrid and Brussels) that these minority nations might settle
for something short of secession. But
there is a curious reluctance to discuss alternatives – especially to
develop further the asymmetric federalism that already exists in the UK
and Spain, where Scotland, Catalonia and the Basque Country already have
more home rule than other regions, yet want still more.There
is no reason why some regions, especially those with a deep-rooted
sense of nation, should not have greater self-rule than others if that
is what they want – the cost, to paraphrase the King James Bible, of
sharing a house of many mansions." The title of the article is "Spain
and Britain should not fear the F-word". Its author, and an increasingly
number of people, certainly have no fear.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment