Trumpism and capitalism

According to Luigi Zingales, Trump is attacking capitalism, and capitalists should unite and resist. Zingales’s piece is a notable attempt to save the face of capitalism: in his view, Trumpism is not a consequence of capitalism but, rather, capitalism is its victim.

However, it is not very convincing to claim that Trumpism has emerged in the country that most strongly symbolizes capitalism, and that this economic system bears no responsibility for the rise of such a serious political pathology.

Zingales argues that “the biggest threat to capitalism has always been the arbitrary abuse of government power.” He also claims that Trump’s behavior is not capitalist but socialist and authoritarian. Yet capitalists—American and otherwise—have themselves abused government power in arbitrary ways, for example in Chile, or have attempted to manipulate it in the United States through campaign finance, lobbying, and corruption.

Zingales further states that “without respect for the rule of law, we cannot have capitalism.” Really? What about Chile under Pinochet, Spain under Franco, and similar cases? He concedes that without the rule of law we may instead have “crony capitalism.” Fair enough—but in that case, capitalism is “crony” in many, many places.

A few years ago, in his book "Capitalism Alone," Branko Milanovic argued that capitalism had been left without competing economic systems after the fall of communism and China’s adoption of a market economy. At the same time, democracy has been eroding in recent decades, with the fastest decline now taking place in the United States. According to data reported by Martin Wolf in the Financial Times, only 7% of the world’s population lives in genuine democracies (down from 17% just a few years ago). It appears that capitalism has advanced while democracy has receded. Admittedly, that 7% also lives under capitalism—but likely a more constrained and better-regulated version than the one found in autocracies or backsliding countries.

There is little doubt that the kind of mafia-style state Trump is promoting is at odds with a certain version of capitalism. But this is an idealized version. Trump represents a frontal attack on both free markets and well-regulated markets. Yet capitalism—an economic system in which economic power is concentrated in the hands of capital owners—can coexist with markets that are neither free nor properly regulated. Neoliberalism, understood as an extreme version of capitalism, coexisted with brutal dictatorships in the twentieth century and has now morphed into a kind of “dark enlightenment,” as described in Quinn Slobodian’s "Hayek’s Bastards."

Some of the world’s wealthiest capitalists are endorsing Trump’s global coup. It might be comforting to believe that anti-capitalists can build a successful democratic alternative. But for now, we may need the support of forward-looking and altruistic capitalists—if they exist, as in the Anthropic model praised by Zingales—who understand that human progress requires more and better democracy, not less. So far, however, it has not been capitalists or other elites who have united against Trumpism, but rather ordinary people in the streets, along with some scientists, intellectuals, and journalists writing on alternative media platforms like Substack.